Bread Pudding with Cinnamon and Vanilla Custard
Bread pudding turns a loaf of plain bread into a warm dessert with a golden top and a soft cinnamon-vanilla center. The exposed bread tips become lightly crisp while the cubes underneath absorb the milk-and-egg custard. It is a useful option for a Thanksgiving table when you want something that can be served straight from a baking dish.
This version uses plain French bread, whole milk and a modest amount of cream. There are no raisins, nuts or alcoholic flavorings in the base, so the texture stays focused on bread and custard. Optional sauces or ice cream can be offered separately.
The recipe makes eight dessert portions in an 8-inch square dish. A short soak helps moisten the cubes evenly, and a thermometer gives a more useful doneness check than browning alone.
Choose bread that can hold the custard
A plain French loaf gives bread pudding enough structure to stay soft without turning completely smooth. Choose a loaf with a light crust and an open but not excessively airy crumb. Very thick, hard crusts can remain chewy after the center has softened.
Day-old bread is convenient, but it should still smell and look sound. Stale bread and spoiled bread are different things; do not use a loaf with mold or an off smell. The oven-drying step is intended to remove a little moisture from good bread, not to make spoiled food usable.
Drying the cubes briefly also makes this recipe practical with a fresh loaf. They should feel dry on the outside and remain pale. Dark toast brings a stronger flavor and can make the upper pieces too hard before the custard finishes baking.
Ingredients and what each one does
The recipe card has the complete measured ingredient list.
- French bread, 300 g: Cut into roughly 1-inch cubes. Similar sizes help the pieces absorb custard at a similar rate.
- Unsalted butter, 25 g: Use a small portion to grease the dish and melt the rest for the custard.
- Four large eggs: These set the liquid into a soft custard. Whisk them thoroughly so no separate strands of white remain.
- Granulated sugar, 100 g: This sweetens the whole dish without requiring a separate sauce.
- Whole milk, 600 ml, and heavy cream, 100 ml: Milk supplies most of the liquid; cream adds richness without making the base entirely cream.
- Alcohol-free vanilla, cinnamon and salt: These season the custard. Check the vanilla label when avoiding alcohol.
Use the bread weight as your main measure. Cups of bread cubes vary considerably with crust, loaf shape and how tightly the cup is packed. Do not press the cubes into a measuring cup to reach a particular volume.
Let the melted butter cool slightly before it joins the eggs. It should remain liquid but no longer feel hot. This keeps the custard easier to whisk evenly.
How to make bread pudding
1. Dry the bread and butter the dish
Heat a conventional oven to 325 °F (160 °C). Spread the bread cubes across a large baking sheet and dry for ten minutes, stirring once. The aim is a pale, dry surface rather than crunchy browned croutons.
Increase the oven to 350 °F (175 °C). Grease an 8-inch (20 cm) square, 2-quart (2-liter) baking dish with 5 g of the butter. A dish that is too shallow can overflow, while a much larger pan makes a thinner pudding that bakes faster.
2. Whisk the custard and soak the cubes
Whisk the eggs and sugar in a large bowl until blended. Add the milk, cream, vanilla, cinnamon, salt and remaining melted butter. Scrape around the bowl so the cinnamon and sugar do not collect in one spot.
Fold in the dried bread, then transfer everything to the prepared dish. Press gently with a spatula so each cube is moistened, leaving a few tips above the surface. Let stand for twenty minutes. If a dry corner remains, spoon a little custard over it rather than crushing the whole mixture.
3. Bake, check the center and let it rest
Bake on the middle rack for 45–50 minutes. The top should be golden and the center should have a gentle wobble rather than a puddle of liquid custard. If the bread tips brown before the middle is ready, tent the dish loosely with foil.
Check the center with a food thermometer, avoiding contact with the baking dish. It needs to reach at least 160 °F (71 °C), consistent with FDA guidance for egg-containing dishes. Let the bread pudding rest for fifteen minutes before cutting or spooning into eight portions.
Substitutions that keep the texture balanced
Brioche or challah can replace the French bread by weight. Both are richer and often sweeter, so expect a softer, more dessert-like result. Check the loaf ingredients if a particular dairy or egg restriction matters.
A sturdy plain sandwich loaf can work, but very soft thin slices absorb liquid quickly. Cut larger pieces and fold gently so they do not dissolve before baking. Avoid changing the bread and liquid amounts at the same time.
Whole milk can replace the measured cream for a lighter-tasting custard, though the finished dish will be less rich. A direct swap to plant milk changes flavor and setting, and replacing the eggs needs a separately designed formula.
For a small variation, use finely grated orange zest in the custard or serve fresh berries alongside. Keep wet fruit out of the base unless you are prepared to adjust for its extra moisture. The plain cinnamon version is easier to judge for doneness.
Troubleshooting
The top is dark but the center is wet. Cover loosely with foil and continue baking until the thermometer reaches the target in the center. A deeper or colder dish may take longer than the suggested range.
The texture is dry. Too much bread, overly hard crusts or excessive baking can all contribute. Weigh the loaf, moisten every cube during the soak and check the custard rather than waiting for every top piece to turn dark brown.
The middle feels dense and smooth. Very soft bread or vigorous stirring may have broken down the cubes. Fold just enough to coat them and keep some visible bread structure.
There is a strong egg flavor. Mix the eggs thoroughly and use the measured vanilla, cinnamon and salt. A custard that has been baked well beyond its setting point can taste more pronounced and feel rubbery.
The portions fall apart when cut. Allow the resting pause. Warm bread pudding is spoonable, but the custard needs a little time to settle before it holds a neat square.
Serving ideas for a holiday dessert table
Serve the pudding warm, with optional accompaniments in separate bowls. A spoonful of cream or a small scoop of vanilla ice cream is enough; the custard already contains sugar and butter.
For a fruit contrast, add baked pears with cinnamon or a few sugared cranberries at serving time. Keep the cranberries separate until the last moment so their sugar coating does not dissolve.
On a larger dessert table, offer small portions alongside coconut macaroons and pecan snowball cookies. The chewy coconut and crumbly cookies provide different textures without needing to add more ingredients to the baking dish.
Make-ahead, storage and reheating
For the simplest make-ahead option, bake the pudding, cool it promptly and refrigerate within two hours. Store covered at 40 °F (4 °C) or below and use within three to four days. Divide a large warm remainder into smaller containers rather than leaving it on the counter until completely cold.
Reheat a portion covered in a moderate oven or microwave until its center reaches 165 °F (74 °C). A small splash of milk can soften a refrigerated portion, but it is not required. Remove the cover briefly at the end if you want to restore a little top texture.
Freeze individual cooled portions in airtight containers for up to two months. Thaw in the refrigerator before reheating. Do not leave an egg custard dessert at room temperature overnight, and return unused portions to the refrigerator promptly.
If organizing ingredients ahead, keep the dry bread and chilled custard separate until you are ready for the measured soak and bake. That preserves the intended texture without requiring an overnight-soaking variation.
Frequently asked questions
Is bread pudding supposed to wobble?
A slight custard wobble is normal, but loose liquid is not. Use the thermometer check in addition to appearance; the center must reach 160 °F (71 °C).
Can I leave out the raisins?
There are no raisins in this base recipe. It is intended to have a simple cinnamon and vanilla flavor.
Why is there liquid at the bottom?
The custard may be underbaked, or the dish may have been cut before resting. Check the center temperature and allow the full resting pause.
Can I double the recipe?
Use two dishes of the original size rather than one very deep dish. Oven crowding can change the baking time, so check both centers independently.
A warm dessert with a simple finish
For bread pudding with a soft custard center and crisp golden tips, weigh the bread, let the cubes soak evenly and use temperature to judge the center. Serve it simply for a Thanksgiving dessert, a winter family meal or an easy way to use a sound loaf of day-old bread.
Bread Pudding with Cinnamon and Vanilla Custard
Ingredients
Method
- Heat a conventional oven to 325 °F (160 °C). Spread the bread cubes on a large baking sheet and dry for 10 minutes, stirring once; they should feel dry outside but remain pale. Increase the oven to 350 °F (175 °C). Grease an 8-inch/20 cm square, 2-quart/2-liter baking dish with 5 g butter.
- Whisk eggs and sugar in a large bowl until evenly combined. Whisk in milk, cream, vanilla, cinnamon, salt and the remaining 20 g melted, cooled butter. Add bread and fold gently. Transfer to the dish, press lightly so every cube is moistened and let stand 20 minutes. Leave a few bread tips exposed.
- Bake on the middle rack for 45–50 minutes until the top is golden and the custard is set with a slight wobble, not a liquid puddle. Insert a food thermometer into the center without touching the dish; it must reach at least 160 °F (71 °C). If the top browns first, tent loosely with foil and continue baking. Rest 15 minutes, then divide into eight portions.
Notes
Get fresh recipes in your inbox
Subscribe to PlateWiser for easy dinners, small-batch treats, and coffee recipes.
Confirm your email to join. Unsubscribe anytime.
